The early 2000s saw a plethora of masterfully shot horror films. Some of them were remakes of successful Japanese films that American directors and producers used in their own way to appeal to Western audiences. Others were original works that brought new stories to the big screen or added a unique touch to a formulaic genre.

However, some horror films of the period received negative reviews from critics who focused too much on the minor flaws contained in a good story. Many of these films deserve to be rewatched because of their characteristic plot twist, strong acting, or story that didn’t appeal to overly eager audiences.

COLLIDER VIDEO OF THE DAY

What Lies Beneath (2000): 47% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

The middle-aged couple seem to be living the perfect life. But when ClaireMichelle Pfeiffer) becomes convinced that her neighbor has killed his wife, she becomes a witness to inexplicable events in her house. But these disturbances are caused by the fact that something hit much closer to home.

With Michelle Pfeiffer and Harrison Ford as leaders and Robert Zemeckis as a director, critics had no choice but to blame the script for several of the film’s shortcomings. The plot does a good job of confusing the audience. Unlike most films in this genre, it focuses on character development rather than moving from one jump scare to another. The main characters play well, solidly, and the ghost story, in which there is neither a teenager nor a child, is quite refreshing.

From Hell (2001): 57% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

Inspector Frederick AbberlineJohnny Depp) tracks down Jack the Ripper as he targets prostitutes in 19th century London.

Many critics chose to reject this film because the plot was not based on fact. It was based on a conspiracy theory surrounding Prince Albert and an illegitimate child he had with a prostitute. Although this theory has been recognized as false by historians, it cannot be denied that a remarkable story has come out of it. Others disagreed with the casting of two Americans as British: Depp as Abberline and Heather Graham like Mary Kelly, one of the prostitutes. Depp’s interpretation of the Inspector as a depressed, opium-addicted widower adds even more darkness to the film’s already bleak atmosphere. Although her British accent leaves much to be desired, Graham is convincing in her role.

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003): 37% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

Five young friends are on their way to a concert when they meet a girl on the way. She seems to be traumatized. While looking for help, the group comes across the killer of the Hewitt family. They Flee as Thomas Hewitt with a Chainsaw (Andrew Briniarski), Leatherface, pursues them.

The fact that the main criticism of this film was its bloodiness, despite the presence of the words “chainsaw” and “massacre” in the title, is puzzling. Several members of the original film crew, including the cameraman. Daniel Pearl, went back to work on it. Its unsettling angles reinforce the sense of dread and entrapment throughout the film. The cast did a good job, but R. Lee ErmeySheriff Hoyt’s interpretation was unnerving.

The Exorcism of Emily Rose (2005): 44% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

Emily Rose (English)Jennifer Carpenter) is tormented by a demon who has taken possession of her. Her family employs a priest, Father Richard Moore (Tom Wilkinson) to perform an exorcism, which fails and results in the death of Emily Rose. Father Moore is then charged with negligent homicide. Erin BrunerLaura Linney), the lawyer representing him puts his career on the line and lets his client tell his story by putting him in the dock.

Based on a tragic true story Anneliese Michelfans exorcist hoping to get the same recipe, were completely deceived by this film. The scenes of possession, while unsettling, contain no gore or vulgarity. The story is told through flashbacks during breathtaking scenes in the courtroom. The presence of the demon looming over Father Moore and his lawyer maintains a sense of dread throughout the film. And despite the fact that this is a horror story, the ending makes viewers think about the nature of human suffering.

The Amityville Horror (2005): 23% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

The Lutzes are looking for a new home. They buy a beautiful house on Long Island at a bargain price, despite knowing that an entire family was murdered inside. Shortly after moving in, disturbing events begin to happen to the Lutzes.

Even though the film deviates from the real stories of Dafoe and the Lutzes, this remake is worth watching if only because of the breathtaking performances of the actors. It is noteworthy that the muted and frightening performance Ryan Reynolds like a possessed George Lutz. Although a little overzealous, but the bloody scenes are effective, and the director (Andrew Douglas) adds a final, unexpected scare moment to make audiences jump as the credits roll.

The Messengers (2007): 11% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

A young family looking for a new life moves into an old, dilapidated farmhouse. Unbeknownst to them, the previous owners were killed by an unknown perpetrator and are now haunting the property.

This film has been criticized for being slow paced and borrowing from previous horror films. But The Pang BrothersChoosing long pauses helps build tension and makes scary scenes more impactful. While some of the tropes have been seen before, the plot is supported by a strong cast, with young Kristin Stewart the role of a teenage daughter in a remarkable unwavering game.

The Eye (2008): 22% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Sydney Wells (English)Jessica Alba) lost her sight in childhood. Years later, she regains the ability to see after a corneal transplant. But along with the gift of sight, these corneas also bring the curse of seeing ghosts.

Criticized as another non-original Japanese remake, the American version is close to the original material. Alba delivers a steady and unassuming performance, keeping the film’s tension throughout the film. Ghostly visions serve their purpose with their creepiness. Although the ending is a little disappointing, the unexpected twist of the plot when Sydney finally sees her picture fully justifies this movie.

Ruins (2008): 49% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

A group of tourists on vacation in Mexico visit ancient Mayan ruins. They are immediately confronted by the Mayan villagers, who force them to climb into the ruins. Trapped at the top, the young hikers soon realize that the creepers surrounding the ruins are out for blood.

This unique story, written Scott Smith and based on his bestseller, was a refreshing option at the time among ghost and slasher movies. The story wastes no time putting its protagonists in immediate danger and doesn’t hesitate to depict bloody scenes. The plot twist is terrible, and Smith still manages to give his film a somewhat sweet ending.

The Strangers (2008): 48% rating on Rotten Tomatoes

A young couple sleeping in a secluded house is terrorized by three masked intruders who have chosen them as their victims.

Approximately based on Tate Murders, this film plays with its protagonists and audiences to a climactic finale. Criticized by harsh critics for its lack of character development, the film makes up for it by offering true psychological horror. The scenes in which the audience is aware of the intruders in the house, but the main characters are not, are exceptionally well-crafted and effectively create tension and apprehension.

Friday the 13th (2009): 25% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Jason Voorhees kills a group of friends camping near the abandoned Camp Crystal Lake.Derek Mears). Six weeks later Clay Miller (Jared Padalecki) appears in the city to find his missing sister. He encounters a group of friends heading to a cabin near Crystal Lake and Jason soon tracks them down as well.

Those who expected a remake of the original were unhappy with this new film. However, this rethinking has its merits. The Jason films were never meant to evoke sympathy for his victims. It’s all about the killings and the originality with which they are committed by Jason. In this version, Jason is a fast-paced killing machine, so every scene he’s in becomes tense. And the unexpected plot twist does what few slashers have done; evoking sympathy for the killer in the audience.