Editor’s Note: The following are spoilers for the first episode of Idol.The newest version of HBO’s Sunday viewing, Idol, has enough premise to cause some controversy before its release. Because the show received so much attention leading up to its June premiere, all eyes were on the series’ two main characters. Lily Rose Depp And Abel TesfayeWeekend), who play Jocelyn and Tedros respectively. As shown in the first episode, Sam Levinson creation does take time, almost to the point of failure, in certain scenes, many of which are more sexually charged than is necessary. Much of the first half of the premiere is devoted to showing Jocelyn in a photo shoot and subsequent dance rehearsal. Bye Idol tries to take us to a “day in the life” of this pop star, which actually ends up with Jocelyn becoming a minor character and the surrounding cast becoming much more interesting.
It’s not the fault of what Depp does in the title role, nor what The Weeknd does in his limited time towards the last half of the episode. It has more to do with how the episode was written. There is a moment in every new show - for many it’s the first few scenes of a premiere - when it’s important to establish what’s going on and what the show is about, or risk losing an audience. If you have no prior knowledge of Idol, you probably thought this show was about a PR team dealing with a nightmare client. This show would be entertaining. This is what was shown during the jump, and this is what ended up being the most exciting, though not meant to be.
Jocelyn’s PR team stole the first episode of Idol
We’ll see if that trend continues over the course of the first season, but the supporting cast we met in the first few scenes is much more interesting. Here is XanderTroy Sivan) as Jocelyn’s creative director with Nikki Katz (Jane Adams) as head of the star’s record company. Both of these characters steal their scenes as Nikki is clearly not hiding anything and we only know everything about her from her words and actions. The same goes for Xander Sivan, the only one who seems to care about everything that happens. Jenny Ruby Jane has a more limited role as background dancer Dianna, but certainly seems like a character worth exploring. Vanity Fair writer Thalia (Hari Nef) is even part of this interesting group, along with many others, including Live Nation spokesman Andrew Finkelstein (Eli Rothwho has only one concern, and that is money. When Dan Levy appears as Benjamin and Hank Azaria like Haim, Jocelyn’s publicist and co-manager respectively, all of these supposed supporting characters grab your attention far more than the actual stars.
Perhaps this was done on purpose. If you look at the message she’s trying to convey, everything that happens in the first half shows that Jocelyn doesn’t really have a say in her career and it’s up to everyone around her. She is a minor character in her own life, as she is in this episode. From that perspective, the show’s reliance on these characters makes a lot of sense. Unfortunately, this takes a lot of energy from the two main characters, because we know what this show should be about, and whenever it starts to delve into darker scenes involving Tedros, it looks like we will demand more scenes. with his PR team than what is actually shown.
‘Idol’ should continue to include Jocelyn’s PR team
There is an ideal world where Idol can give us more of what we want. Although the premiere received some criticism, the second half of the episode, when the main characters actually work together, was the most boring moment of the premiere. What, as they say, Idol took a slow approach to introduce us to Jocelyn and Tedros so the payback will eventually come (hopefully!). Depp’s solo performance (especially that opening scene in the photo shoot) gives us enough confidence that this character could end up in a more interesting position. What Idol however, already successful, gathers an entertainment group around his leader, which is sometimes the hardest thing to do.
Now that the main characters have met, we can expect their twisted narrative to start playing out. What shouldn’t happen is no screen time for all those members of Jocelyn’s PR team. Instead of, Idol it’s best if he strikes that balance from now on, giving us just enough supporting characters that he doesn’t outshine Depp or The Weeknd, but also allows them both to share the spotlight. Idol the start was rocky, partly due to the press pre-dating its release and the dubious first episode. Regardless, there’s a premise here that could make this thing work if put right. What we saw in the second half was much less interesting than the chaotic first half focused on damage control. If the latter can remain central to this show, then Idol has a chance to deploy this ship. We deserve to see more of Levi, Azaria, Sivian and Adams!
First episode Idol is available to stream on Max, with new episodes of the show airing every Sunday night.
Source: Collider
I have worked as a journalist for over 7 years and have written for many different publications. I currently work as an author at Daily News Hack, where I mostly cover entertainment news. I have a great deal of experience in the industry and am always looking to learn more. I am a highly motivated individual who is always looking to improve my skills. I am also a very friendly and personable person, which makes me easy to work with.
