The popularity of historical dramas is on the rise, but not all of these series are based on the real story of their time period. With shows like Queen Charlotte: The Bridgerton Story And Great choosing your own path in the subject, it is clear that the truth is not a priority. Both roles, Charlotte (India Amarteifio) and Ekaterina (Elle Fanning), feature real-life women from history, and the shows touch on their struggles with their respective marriages, but neither show catches up in accuracy. Bye Queen Charlotte created with the concept of alternative history, Great takes a different approach, claiming that it is “sometimes true”. While they may seem similar, they are slightly different. concept of something Queen Charlotte makes one clear change: Charlotte’s race and how it affects English society. Meanwhile, Great takes liberties with whatever he chooses, never claiming that anything is strictly true.



However, both of these approaches set the show apart from more realistic examples of the genre. Historical dramas are often closely tied to history, such as Crown, which may occasionally come off as part of a documentary. Of course, he interprets the passages and adds conversations that were never written down, but the main points of the plot are stolen from the history book. Liberty Great And Queen Charlotte benefiting from their loose approach to history allows for increased variety and unpredictability. In addition, do not touch on real events so that these shows do not take on a lighter and more humorous tone. These not-so-historical dramas prove that a genre doesn’t always need precision to be good.

Alternate history of Queen Charlotte adds variety

Image via Netflix

Queen Charlotte and his predecessor bridgerton, actively chose not to follow the traditional appearance of English high society, adding people of all races to the ranks of the world. While the race of the historical figure has been questioned, it is certain that no matter how Charlotte may have looked, the wider society never integrated as a result. However, these series cleverly use the idea of ​​alternative history to add variety to the cast. It not only sets Bridgerton separately, but especially with Queen Charlotte, adds spice to the plots of many characters that would otherwise not exist. It’s a simple change, but it has several long-term benefits.

Queen Charlotte uses historical freedom in other ways. Bridgerton little about historical events or people, with the exception of Charlotte and the occasional appearance of her husband. Instead, the show focuses on marriages and gossip about the characters’ personal lives. However, with royal leadership, Queen Charlotte adventures in more historic waters. There is some truth in the story of George and Charlotte – King George (Corey Milkchrist) is struggling with insanity and the couple did have fifteen children, but there is also no evidence that Charlotte ever actually tried to climb the garden wall to avoid her wedding. However, the fact that the story isn’t the focus of the show makes it lighter. This is not the life of real people, but their fictional version. Not everything should be taken so seriously unless it is portrayed as a literal representation of the story. While many things are realistic, the show doesn’t tie in too closely with historical figures and changes things up when needed.

“Great” takes a more absurd approach to history

Nicholas Hoult and Elle Fanning in The Great Season 3
Image via Hulu

With a note that history is only sometimes true, Great takes a general concept from the life of Catherine the Great and tells her own story. While the names are largely the same, the story as a whole is highly inaccurate, to the point where calling it historical in any sense of the word seems to be a misnomer. This allows for more unpredictability: characters live longer and die differently than their historical counterparts. Unforeseen twists add to the story, though often remove it from its historical roots. But since the show doesn’t claim to be accurate, the deviation doesn’t really matter.

An unrealistic approach Great joke, include a level of absurdity, and ultimately be a satirical representation of the story. If the show was accurate, it couldn’t have PeterNicholas Hoult) to be who he is and cannot include the absurdity that the show is based on. The show’s irreverent tone is a direct result of its lack of precision. Great picks up any plot points from the story, but quickly ignores everything else, and that’s for the best. The show does not pretend to be taken seriously, as can be seen from the slightest clip. Great exaggerates characters to draw attention to erroneous norms throughout the story. Whether it’s a comparison of Katherine’s strategic battle planning, Peter’s ineptitude at war, or a literal child trying to duel a man sleeping with his wife, the show’s absurdity has purpose but also adds humor. Maybe not exactly, but Great takes a general description of the life of Catherine the Great and turns it into a captivating series unlike anything that has come before.

“The Great Ones” and “Queen Charlotte” Don’t Have to Be Accurate

Image via Hulu

While these shows are based on historical figures, they do not accurately represent history. Unlike many other historical dramas that focus on the smallest details in order to realistically represent the past, Queen Charlotte And Great actively change things to make their stories unique. This can cause problems by misleading the public as to what happened in real life, but neither show hides the fact that their basis is vague. In fact, these shows may not represent reality, but there is enough truth in them that many fans would rather explore the story on their own. So history is still taught, but not directly from these series.

Alternative stories about Queen Charlotte And Great make less serious shows with unpredictable stories and diverse actors that wouldn’t have happened with hard historical accuracy. These series never pretend to be realistic and use this fact to their advantage. Clearly, there is a market for this approach. Queen Charlotte And Great they may not be good sources of history, but they are entertaining, which is the ultimate goal of television.

Great available for streaming on Hulu while Queen Charlotte: The Bridgerton Story available for streaming on Netflix.